The Daily Weekly News, Politics, and Media

Afternoon 'Don't Forget Your Sunscreen' Edition
Posted May 16; 03:00 pm

Reverb Music & Nightlife

Too Many Shows Tonight
Posted May 16; 01:56 pm

Voracious Food News and Reviews

What's Better Than One Award-Winning Brewer?
Posted May 16; 04:11 pm

Thread Count Arts, People, and Style

Why We Need Daily Newspaper Arts Coverage
Posted May 16; 08:48 pm

Buzzer Beater Seattle Sports

Don't Drink And Drive a Golf Cart
Posted May 16; 05:51 pm


Slideshows

Newsletters

Stay up-to-date with the Seattle Weekly. We'll e-mail you a detailed rundown of what's on seattleweekly.com once a week.

Signing up is simple and you can opt out anytime. Give it a try.

Web Feeds

Use one of the buttons below to subscribe to Seattle Weekly's full Web feed. Or choose from our full list of Web feeds.

- For Newsreaders

- For Home Pages

Free Classifieds Seattle, WA

Am I a Fake Seattleite?

March 5, 2008

Rod Filbrandt

Dear Uptight Seattleite,

I just started a firestorm of controversy in an online forum by asking this question: Is it OK to tell people you live in Seattle if you actually live in the 'burbs? And so I put it to you: Are you a Seattleite if you live in, say, Maple Valley or Edmonds? Or only if you live within the actual city limits? What if you're talking to someone from out of town, like Nashville or Los Angeles—is it OK then to say you're "from Seattle"? What about when you're visiting Portland? Are there different rules depending on who you're talking to? Can you define the term "Seattleite" for us? Are there geographic limits associated with this noun? How far outside of Seattle is it not Seattle anymore?Jamie in Uptown

Dear Jamie,

How are you today? Do you have a dog? Have you ever tried to knit? Is it raining where you are? What color is your parachute? What are you thinking about for lunch? Have you been to that teriyaki place? Do you think it's going to be nice this weekend, and if so, what do you consider "nice"? Sunny but cold—is that "nice"? And did you drink about 30 cups of coffee today, or are you always so perky and inquisitive?

Sorry for teasing you, Jamie! I guess I'm just in a good mood, what with the light coming back and all. Also, I made a connection on democraticsingles.net the other day. While I won't be so crude as to say that some "mission" was "accomplished," well, a bit of intimacy does improve a person's outlook, doesn't it?

Anyway, I'd like to address what I think is the question behind all your questions. Namely, why would a Kirklander, Kentian, or Bothellite say they were from Seattle to begin with? Because they see their own town as a wasteland—a sprawling, earth-choking labyrinth of six-lane roads, fast food, nail salons, and craft-supply stores? And they therefore wish to identify instead with the cultural prestige and excellent bookstores of Seattle? I'm just trying to empathize here. And as best as I can make out, there's no problem. We all have our comforting little delusions.

Dear Uptight Seattleite,

I'm a 24 year-old man who has realized that my friends' S.A.D. symptoms have been giving me a contact depression. But instead of cutting them off, I've decided to balance out the time I spend with them by doing things I enjoy alone. These things turn out to include independent film/music/etc., post-punk culinary arts, compulsive blog scanning, and Victorian novels. This is a wondrous 180 from how I was in college. I'm becoming more self-aware, cosmopolitan, and articulate. But the more culturally aware I become, the more I can't relate to my fellow human beings. Case in point: a dinner party last night, which ended in uncomfortable silence following an extended riff I did on the surprising indie hit of the season. Am I to die friendless and alone, remembered only for the clever references I sent whistling over my friends' heads?Keller Schmeckle

Dear Keller Schmeckle,

It can be difficult when your cultural acumen zips ahead with a speed that leaves your companions bobbing mutely in your wake. I myself have had the painful experience of trying to talk to someone who hasn't heard of Noam Chomsky and incorrectly uses the word "ironically."

My advice is to bend like the reed and be like the Mountain. KMTT 103.7, that is. You know how they mix in classics like "Layla" and "Don't Stand So Close to Me" with stuff by newer, less familiar artists like Matchbox 20? You, too, have to take your audience along slowly. So if you're talking politics, for example, start off with the kind of catchy Bush-hating ditty that everyone likes to cluck along with. Then bring in the more subtle stuff: "But of course it really comes down to class." Hit the snare at regular intervals with phrases like "of course" and "what people need to understand" so your audience still has some cues. When you've got a good groove going, change up the meter with some choice piece of history. "Of course, Nixon was as liberal as Obama in a lot of ways!" Bam! Now you're driving your stake into new land. I'm pretty sure my new Democratic friend appreciated how I practiced this technique the other night, although she was pretty quiet at the time and hasn't called me back for a few days now.

Have a question for the Uptight Seattleite? Send it to uptight@seattleweekly.com.

Comments (7)

Reader Comments

1. Comment by Jay K. — March 05, 2008 @ 7:31PM
You can CLAIM to "live in Seattle" no matter where you actually sleep, eat, and fornicate, but we'll always be able to tell a faux Seattleite when we see her. I could tell you how we separate the REAL Seattleite-wheat from the FAKE Seattleite-chaff, but then I'd have to kill you! This vow is part of our Secret Initiation. I can say no more.
2. Comment by really2008 — March 06, 2008 @ 4:12PM
Jay--You mean the hairy legs? That secret is out.
3. Comment by Lao — March 10, 2008 @ 6:30PM
To Fake Seattleite,

If you are across the country or out of the country and you for example, live in Bothell, then yes, you say you are from Seattle.. otherwise people give you a weird look and say, "You live in Brothel?" and have no idea where you are from. Then you are forced to explain that it is just North of Seattle and begin wishing you just said Seattle in the first place.
But if you are drinking with friends on Capitol Hill and someone asks where you live, you say Bothell, Edmonds, etc. Because if you say Seattle to someone who lives on Union and really you live on Woodenville Road then you'll be a liar.

So it all depends on the location and situation.
4. Comment by Kim — March 11, 2008 @ 12:02AM
If I meet someone out of state and ask them where they are from, and they respond "Seattle," I instantly ask what part, since I grew up here, and I'm curious. If they then say "Snohomish" I'll get that look on my face that says "Yeah right you're not from Seattle." So I guess I'm stuck up that way, but I grew up living between Ballard and Shoreline mostly, so I always say "North Seattle" in case the person asking is from somewhere more central.
5. Comment by Mr. Noir — March 16, 2008 @ 1:27AM
"Am I a Fake Seattleite?" Well, honestly who wants to be a real Seattleite? I mean the best part about Seattle are the people that moved here from other places vs the natives....... hmmmmmm, the descriptor hillbilly comes to mind.
6. Comment by Olga — March 26, 2008 @ 5:41AM
I used to live in Seattle (okay, Shoreline, to be more exact) and moved to Arlington, VA after college. But I sometimes tell people I live in Washington DC :) I believe people in NYC have the same issue. It's all universal http://cooking-shopping-crafts-etc.blogspot.com/
7. Comment by Real non-seattleite — April 04, 2008 @ 6:36PM
kkkkk. 100% agree with Mr. Noir. Are there people worried about not "passing for a Seattleite". Really? Give me a break...

* indicates required fields. Please enable browser cookies before filling out this form. All reader comments are subject to our Terms of Use. By clicking Add Comment, you acknowledge that you have reviewed and agree to these Terms.




(Characters are case sensitive)

Comments may take a few moments to process and appear on the site. Please do not click the "Add Comment" button again while your comment is being added.

Most 
Popular

now click this

Travel
Pacific Northwest Getaways

Seattle Home Search
1000's of Listings and Detailed Neighborhood Information

Seattle Weekly Online Career Fair!
Where People & Jobs Find Each Other.

Sound Living ®
Seattle Metro Real Estate


To Do List

Saturday, May 17

Dead Meadow, SubArachnoid Space, Whalebones, Patrol
Man, the stoners haven't had a pairing this perfect since Comets on Fire pl... More>>
El Corazon, Sat., May 17, 7:00pm, $10 adv./$12

Peter Bagge
Artist Peter Bagge will show off a form of panels from Hate, his pioneering... More>>
Fantagraphics Bookstore & Gallery, Sat., May 17, 6:00pm-9:00pm

Thee Emergency (CD release), the Valley, the Hands
With Dita Vox at the helm, Seattle garage-rock band Thee Emergency speciali... More>>
King Cobra, Sat., May 17, 8:00pm

174 more things to do today>>
Find a Restaurant

 
A work of love from charismatic man-about-town Waid Sainvil, Waid's is the only Haitian restaurant o...
Off the Delridge Way exit from the West Seattle Bridge, Skylark Cafe & Club is a genuine blue-collar...
The Northlake Tavern is proud to tell you that its small pie weighs more than two-and-a-half pounds ...
Entering Can Can is like walking into Moulin Rouge—not the Parisian tourist trap, the Baz Luhrmann m...
Find a Concert

Saturday, May 17
Our Top Picks
Check out our Digital Jukebox!
Find a Movie

Find a Theater

Find a Club

The groan-inducingly named Thai One On in Lake City dims its lights and switches on the speakers at ...
Seattle resident Gabe Morgan was once in a constant mental, physical, and psychological battle with ...
I haven't eaten much steak this summer because I'm usually broke. When I discovered Ozzie's Wednesda...
Pure, unadulterated joy is the look permanently affixed to the face of a man doing the mambo to the ...
It's Saturday night between 10th and 11th on Pike Street, Capitol Hill's bustling new epicenter. The...
national

Headlines from Coast to Coast

SF Weekly

Viva Farolito!

Former pros from Latin America help make an "amateur" soccer team unstoppable. More >>

Village Voice

The Barely Legal Empire of Tony Alamo

A nutty polygamist pastor rebuilds his church--with help from New Yorkers. More >>

Miami New Times

Love is No Contract

A Florida man sues his girlfriend-for dumping him. More >>

Houston Press

The Myth of the Bachelor's Degree

A growing number of educators face a hard truth: not every kid is college material. More >>